Welcome Party

Wedding Ceremony

Wedding Reception

Cocktails & Hors d'oeuvres

Dinner & Dancing

Brunch

Our Wedding

Our love journey is anything but ordinary. It all began on the banks of Putah Creek in Winters, California—a place that would become much more than a favorite fishing spot. Sarah had been casting lines there since 2020 while working at the world-famous French Laundry, often finding peace in the quiet waters and the rhythm of fly fishing. Over time, she got to know the creek well and became friendly with a local guide who admired her skill and spirit. Around that time, Jeff—an avid fly fisherman with plenty of years and rivers under his belt—was looking to fish Putah Creek for the first time. He happened to connect with the same guide, who quickly realized he had the perfect person for Jeff to meet. “You’ve got to fish with Sarah,” the guide said. “She knows this creek like the back of her hand. And she’s a firefighter, just like you.” With Sarah’s permission, the guide passed along her number. Jeff reached out, and—after a few days (a true test of patience for any fisherman)—Sarah responded. What started as a casual friendship soon blossomed into something deeper. They shared so much: a love for the outdoors, good food, fly fishing, firefighting, and a grounded outlook on life.&nbsp; Their first official meetup was in American Canyon, where Jeff picked Sarah up for breakfast in Napa. From that morning on, they were inseparable.&nbsp;The connection felt easy, real, and undeniable.&nbsp;&nbsp;At a Matisyahu concert in Sacramento they&nbsp;made a steady commitment to each other&nbsp;and they've been reeling each other in ever since. And while Jeff may have&nbsp;more years of&nbsp;fly fishing experience, somehow, Sarah always catches the bigger fish. He says it’s rigged; she says it’s talent.&nbsp;&nbsp;Oh—and despite working at The French Laundry, Sarah still hasn’t cooked Jeff a full French Laundry meal… but she managed to win his heart anyway. What started with a love of fishing became the greatest catch of all. Two firefighters, one spark—and a lifelong adventure ahead.&nbsp;&nbsp;Proof that sometimes the best love stories start with a fly rod and a little bit of luck.

Our Story

Photos

Welcome PartyFriday, May 15, 20266:00 PM–9:00 PMAttire: Island CasualMargaritaville (aka "Manhattanville") Theme Sailfish Point Country Club - Beach Club2201 SE Sailfish Point BoulevardStuart, Florida 34996

St. Joseph Catholic Church1200 SE 10th Street, Stuart, FL 34996 Wedding Party Maid of Honor: Caroline HollanderMatron of Honor: Peggy DermodyBridesmaids: • Dana Bayersdorfer • Ann Backof • Stephanie Kinnare • Sara OrdonezJunior Bridesmaid: Jessica Ordonez Best Man: Gary MahlbergGroomsmen: • Tim Ordonez • Ted Ordonez • Mike Bayersdorfer • Bradley Backof • Alex WalgreenJunior Groomsman: Jack Backof Tiny VIPsFlower Girl: Sophie BayersdorferRing Bearer: Marty BayersdorferRing Security: Desi Backof &amp; Will Backof Mother of the Bride:Mary Beth Bayersdorfer Father of the Bride:Rich Bayersdorfer Mother of the Groom:Louise Ordonez ✝️ Father of the Groom:Joseph Ordonez ✝️

Ceremony 

Wedding ReceptionMay 16, 20264:30 PM–10:30 PMAttire:&nbsp;Black Tie PreferredSailfish Point Country Club - Ocean Room2201 SE Sailfish Point BoulevardStuart, Florida 34996

Reception

BrunchSunday, May 17, 20269:30 AM–12:30 PMAttire: CasualThe Bayersdorfer Residence6994 SE Harbor CircleStuart, Florida 34996

Sunday Brunch

We have a discounted rate room block - Bayersdorfer/Ordonez - for which reservations need to be made by calling the number above or using the following <a href="https://reservations.opalcollection.com/hutchinson-shores/availability.asp?startDate=05/14/2026&amp;endDate=05/17/2026&amp;requesttype=invBlockCode&amp;code=5452754#&amp;openWidget=1" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">Reservation Website</a>. Reservations must be made by April 6. Rates are effective for 2 days prior and after the weekend. If you have any difficulty please call Rich (973-224-1753) or Mary Beth (973-224-1752) Bayersdorfer.

Hutchinson Shores Resort & Spa

Hotel

General Transportation - Friday Welcome Party (6pm–9pm) - Transportation on your ownTravel time between Hutchinson Shores Resort and Spa (3793 NE Ocean Blvd, Jensen Beach) and Sailfish Point (2201 Sailfish Point Blvd, Stuart) is about 15 minutes and one turn. After entering thru Sailfish Gate (your name will be at security), turn left at the clubhouse sign (on your left) and proceed to porte cochere for valet parking. Saturday Wedding Ceremony (1:30pm) - For those at Hutchinson Shores, we will have a bus from the resort departing promptly at 12:30pm and returning to the resort at the end of the Ceremony. Alternatively, you may drive on your own. Travel time between the resort and St. Joseph's Church (1200 SE 10th St, Stuart) is about 20 minutes. Ceremony begins promptly at 1:30. Please arrive early. Saturday Reception (4:30pm–10:30pm) -For those at Hutchinson Shores, we will have a bus from the resort departing promptly at 4:00 and returning from Sailfish at the end of the reception. Alternatively, you may also choose to drive on your own. Sunday Brunch at Bayersdorfer Residence (9:30am–12:30pm) - (6994 SE Harbor Circle) Transportation on your own. General Notes on Travel Coming to Sailfish - MacArthur Blvd is a 2-mile narrow, curvy street that ends at our Sailfish community. The speed limit is 25 mph. Please drive carefully. Ubers or taxis are not a viable option. If you have questions, contact our wedding planner Elizabeth Hollman at 561-596-1916, or if needed, Rich (973-224-1753) or Mary Beth (973-224-1752).

Transportation 

Sarah and Jeff's Honeymoon Fund

As we all know Sarah and Jeff love to travel and make memories. To be able to do so, the wedding website can be opened on another phone or computer to be able to scan the QR code in your banking app. Thank you so much for making their dreams come true!

OUR REGISTRY

Bloomingdale's Registry <a href="https://www.bloomingdales.com/registry/Sarah-Bayersdorfer-Jeffrey-Ordonez/1112080" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">https://www.bloomingdales.com/registry/Sarah-Bayersdorfer-Jeffrey-Ordonez/1112080</a>

Honeymoon Fund / Our Registry

Bloomingdale's Registry <a href="https://www.bloomingdales.com/registry/Sarah-Bayersdorfer-Jeffrey-Ordonez/1112080" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">https://www.bloomingdales.com/registry/Sarah-Bayersdorfer-Jeffrey-Ordonez/1112080</a>

Our Registry 

HOLD

Q & A (under construction)

Q + A (under construction)

Historic Stuart, Florida is known for its coastal charm and small town feel. It was recently named #1 Best Coastal Small Town by USA Today Reader's Choice Awards. Stuart is also known as the "Sailfish Capital of the World". Overall it is a friendly and welcoming community with a relaxed pace of life.

Hutchinson Shores Resort &amp; SpaBeach AccessPool Resort &amp; Spa Access

Hutchinson Island ActivitiesElliot Museum (Monday to Sunday 10am-5pm)House of Refuge Museum (Monday to Saturday 10am-4pm, Sunday 1pm-4pm)Local Lanes - Duckpin Bowling, Food and Drinks (Wednesday to Saturday 4pm-12am, Sunday 12pm-8pm)

Shopping and Restaurants in Downtown StuartOur Favorite Restaurant - Riverwalk Cafe and Oyster BarOur Favorite Ice Cream - Kilwin's Shopping - Osceola Street

Restaurants in Jensen BeachConchy Joe's and Lures

Things to Do

Travel Time to/from Airports to Hutchinson Island: Palm Beach International Airport (PBI) - 1 hour Fort Lauderdale International Airport (FLL) - 1 hour 45 minutes Miami International Airport (MIA) - 2 hours Orlando International Airport (MCO) - 2 hours 15 minutes While Uber, Lyft and other car services are available, such local services are limited and most travelers have found car rentals to be preferable.

Sarah & Jeff

Sarah & Jeff

Photos